The Global Mail has ceased operations.
Powerhouse

Let’s Talk About Indonesia

Revelations on Monday that Australian spies successfully tapped the phone of Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, and those of his wife and inner circle, have unsurprisingly been the cause of much chatter in parliament.

But if “Indonesia” features heavily in Hansard transcripts this week, that’s not exceptional. Prime Minister Tony Abbott has repeatedly assured our northern neighbour that Australia’s relationship with Indonesia is “the single most important [one] we have”. And if mentions in parliament are any measure of a country’s importance in Australian eyes, then Hansard certainly bears out the PM’s sentiment.

Particularly since 2012, neither the United States, nor China, nor even a country so indelibly linked to Australia as New Zealand, has consumed parliament’s attention as Indonesia has.

PartyLines reveals a relationship that’s both intense — “Indonesia” being one of the few mainstay issues in Hansard, rating a mention almost every week since 2006 — and rocky, with one crisis after another sending “Indonesia” spiking in the charts.

The PartyLines tool crunches Hansard data from 2006 onwards. That year sees the first big “Indonesia” spike around August, when the then-Howard government tried to toughen up Australia’s asylum-seeker policy by ordering that all boat arrivals be processed offshore.

Earlier that year, 43 asylum seekers from the restive Indonesian province of West Papua made land in Australia, claiming, per the United Nations Refugee Convention, a “well-founded fear of persecution” by Indonesian authorities. The immigration department granted them temporary protection visas, to the dismay of Indonesia’s president Yudhoyono.

The incident was sufficiently serious that Indonesia’s ambassador was recalled to Jakarta, the last occasion on which such a drastic step was taken — until this week, that is.

In the 2006 crisis, meetings between PM Howard and his Indonesian counterpart eventually soothed tensions. Jakarta’s ambassador was re-installed in Canberra, and the tough new asylum-seeker processing laws were widely seen as Australia’s peace offering to Indonesia, designed as they were to deter West Papuans from making the journey in future.

<p>Dudi Anung/Presidential Palace via Getty Images</p>

Dudi Anung/Presidential Palace via Getty Images

Then Prime Minister John Howard meets with President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono in Indonesia in June 2006.

Incidentally, transcripts from that week make for interesting reading (select week 32, 2006). Labor, the Greens, and Liberal moderates together mounted an impassioned defence of the right to seek asylum, and of Australia’s obligation to protect the world’s persecuted. Their protests succeeded in derailing the bill. Mandatory offshore processing was abandoned, considered unbearably inhumane – 2006 was a long time ago.

Asylum seekers also prompted the second — and largest — spike in mentions of “Indonesia” in PartyLines.

It occurs in November 2009, when a boat in distress carrying 78 asylum seekers was spotted by an Australian customs vessel, the Oceanic Viking – as we now know, it was around about this time, that Australian spies were tuning into Mr and Mrs Yudhoyono’s phone calls.

The boat, its passengers all Sri Lankan Tamils, was found drifting in Indonesia’s search-and-rescue zone; it was towed by the Oceanic Viking to a detention centre on the Indonesian island of Bintan. For a month, the Tamils refused to budge from the vessel, until November 17, the week “Indonesia” spiked in Hansard.

The third peak, more a high plateau, comes as a sustained, month-long surge in the Asian nation’s parliamentary mentions, which begins shortly after the ABC Four Corners program’s infamous May 2011 report, “A Bloody Business”. The program exposed the brutal treatment of Australian cattle in Indonesian slaughterhouses, and prompted the then-Gillard government to suspend live-cattle exports to the country.

Though the trade resumed after a month, relations with our northern neighbour took far longer to recover, with strict quotas imposed on Australian cattle exports to Indonesia for more than two years after the ban. Quotas were lifted in October. There are fears that this week’s spying revelations might lead to them again being tightened.

The two years since that episode see “Indonesia” feature consistently in parliamentary transcripts.

“Repair[ing] relations with Indonesia that have been so damaged by this government,” as then-opposition foreign affairs spokeswoman Julie Bishop promised to do in August 2012, became a Coalition talking point in the lead-up to this year’s election. And as the numbers of asylum seekers spiked throughout 2012/13, so too did mentions of Indonesia surge and remain high.

The weeks to come are likely to see another spike, prompted by another crisis. The Coalition government, looking to rebuild its relationship with our neighbour, must hope that mentions of Indonesia in Hansard eventually taper, and stay down.

That’s because, if the pattern in PartyLines is any indication, when Australian politicians are talking about Indonesia, rarely is it for good reasons.

7 comments on this story
by John Fraser

"My question is to the Prime Minister. I refer the Prime Minister to the suspension of the live cattle trade with Indonesia and the unfolding disaster that this entails for cattle producers across Northern Australia. Is the Prime Minister prepared to meet with me, urgently, so that we can work together on a bipartisan basis to re-open this trade as soon as possible, at least for those Indonesian abattoirs that already fully meet Australian standards?" ... Abbott 14/6/2011

"My first duty is to protect Australia and to advance our nationalist interest, and I will never, ever depart from that," Abbott 18/11/2013

How's that going ?

"Murdoch and Abbott lied to Australians".

November 21, 2013 @ 8:27pm
by John Fraser

Impressed with the Party Lines interactive graph.

Just can't wait for the NBN to arrive ..... oh shit ! that's right the coalition are going to scrap it.

November 21, 2013 @ 8:29pm
by gabrianga

That's for sure John. Just as they scrapped that other overpriced under performing piece of rubbish....the Labor Government.

November 23, 2013 @ 8:50am
by Kel

I always find it hard to fathom attitudes such as yours gabrianga. Of course you are allowed to hate the Labor Party but my take on the last six years was a government that spent billions to keep Australians in work, to build infrastructure and to attempt to change the Australian economy to one based on renewable energy. Of course I acknowledge the leadership fiasco fanned by the media, but it was agreed internationally to be a economically successful government.

Now the LNP are back and they have given money to the well off, are prepared to bring back non means tested payments, institute a hugely expensive PPL for the highly paid, they have taken payments from the lower paid as well as from their superannuation, they have re-instituted a tax dodge for non business car owners, they have repealed taxes which will affect the budget bottom line and accordingly Crazy Joe has to blow out the budget which is a monstrous backflip. Tony's performance on the world stage has been laughable, Morrison treats all with disdain, Joyce predictably is out of his depth and they have managed to turn the Parliament into a star chamber.

Presumably all this meets with your approval gabrianga?

November 23, 2013 @ 11:14pm
Show previous 4 comments
by Chris

Yes the mob of troglodytes are ruining the our countries chance to compete on the forefront of the digital revolution purely for the benefit of Murdoch's Foxtel business. Also taking us backwards in regards to social equity, education and in regards to action on climate change. We now have the over priced, under achieving, over promising children at the wheel. As Keating said god help Australia under an Abbott Liberal government.

November 24, 2013 @ 2:05am
by Rodney E Lever

Swapped now for a much nastier piece of rubbish, money grabbing and over performing!

November 24, 2013 @ 9:29am
by Frederika Steen

Some research released earlier this year by or for DFAT showed the Australian people to be alarmingly ignorant about its northern neighbour... geography, government, culture etc Some of our politicians are not much better it seems. Can you identify the research report/... it has contextual value for the current discussions.

November 25, 2013 @ 3:03am
CLOSE
Type a keyword to search for a story or journalist

Journalists

Stories